GET A QUOTE &

START SAVING

GET A QUOTE &

START SAVING

About Us  

An Independent Agency Specializing in Home & Auto Insurance

At Colorado Insurance we pride ourselves on building long-lasting client relationships through honesty, integrity, professionalism and a commitment to ensure you and your family are properly protected from life’s unplanned disasters. We truly believe that we serve our community families better than anyone in Colorado. This is done by focusing our energy and resources on our client. Through determining their needs and level of risk, we are able to find the perfect insurance program to fit their lives. With over 25 years of experience in the Colorado insurance market, our agency excels at providing coverage for both commercial lines of business as well as personal lines including but not limited to auto insurance, home insurance, umbrella insurance and much more. We take great pride in the industry leading insurance products we offer as a result of contracts with over twelve preferred insurance carriers. This guarantees that we are offering the best price, protection and service possible.

COVERAGE CLOSE TO HOME 

You don’t have to look far to find us. Based out of Littleton, Colorado, we pride ourselves on servicing our surrounding area as well as the far reaches of the state. As a locally-based company we know the risks specific to the state and know how to protect you against them. From hailstorms to wildfires we’ve seen it all and we are with you every step of the way.

WHY WE’RE THE BEST

Competitive Pricing

The beautiful thing about choosing Colorado Insurance is the versatility of having more then 12 different preferred insurance carriers at your finger tips!! The insurance markets are ever changing and what may seem like a competitive insurance rate today may not be a competitive insurance rate tomorrow. Our focus is to manage your insurance policies and ensure you are always receiving the best available combination of coverage and premium between the companies we represent by offering annual customer reviews. Whether you are looking for an insurance policy for your car, truck, motorcycle, home, boat or any other ATV, we will be able to find you a very competitive rate to meet all your families insurance needs. You will never have to worry about your rates and your pricing ever again!!

Annual Insurance Policy Reviews

Our new client acquisition process is just the beginning!! We are here to be your professional insurance adviser for the life of your policies!! Every year our goal is to remain in communication with you, review your insurance policies, adjust your insurance coverage, introduce new insurance products if need be and ensure all of your specific insurance needs are being met. We do this by offering annual policy reviews to all of our clients!. At Colorado Insurance you are a preferred client and our goal is to keep it that way!!

Specialized Insurance Product Focus

We are focused, we are specialized, and we are dedicated to personal lines insurance. We are good at what we do and we are confident to let you know about it!! If you need a home loan, you see a mortgage professional. If you need to invest your money, you see an investment professional. If you want to buy a new home, you find the best available real estate professional, etc. Why should your insurance be any different? If you are in the market for insurance for any of the following: auto, home, car, truck, motorcycle, motor-home, boat, trailer or any other ATV, we promise you, you have found the finest independent insurance company in Colorado!!

Colorado Insurance Gives Back 

Colorado Insurance came together again this summer to team up with Integrated Family Community Services (IFCS) to help provide backpacks, school supplies and a first day of school outfit to local children. We’ve had the pleasure of working with this organization for several years running and we love it.

This year, Colorado Insurance was able to provide supplies and backpacks to 75 children in the Ready, Set, School! Program helping to contribute to the total 340 backpacks they were able to give out. IFCS works to help support local, low income families by providing financial assistance, food, clothing and transportation assistance.

Over the past three years, Colorado Insurance has helped to sponsor a total of 225 students providing them with the tools and supplies for a successful school year and we are looking forward to the next Ready, Set, School! Program in 2020!

Birthday Party for a

Local Orphanage

Our Directors of Sales – Robin Czarnek held a community outreach event with her team of sales agents. She and her team hosted a birthday party for a local orphanage in their area called Boysville, where they represented Colorado insurance, spread their kindness and served the community.

Colorado Insurance Food Drive

 
The Team at Colorado Insurance has been diligently working to collect canned, shelf-stable goods and toiletries for the yearly 9Cares Colorado Shares Food Drive. The 9Cares Colorado Shares organization has worked tirelessly for 37 years to help wipe out hunger in Colorado. The donations collected will be distributed to over 130 food banks across the state.
 
This weekend, The Colorado Insurance Team headed to the store to stock up on additional donations for the food drive. We’ve shared some photos of the team in action!

Children’s Hospital Colorado

This December, Colorado Insurance coordinated a toy drive for the Children’s Hospital Colorado. Our generous employees collected toys all of which were sure to brighten the lives of the kids that spent their holidays in the hospital. Colorado Insurance graciously contributed as well, which brought the grand total of in-kind and monetary contributions to $2,000!

Meet The Team 

Leadership Team

Mike Mathisen

Management, CO

President

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

 

Sarah Zambrano

Management, CO

Operations Manager

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Molly Lura

Personal Lines Service, CO

Customer Service Manager

O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kirsten Jones

Personal Lines Service, CO

Business Development Manager

O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

 

Rob Oldenburg

Business Development Manager, CO

M: 720-327-3282 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

William Marquez

IT Admin, CO

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Valerie Cekovsky 

Corporate Recruiter

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Directors of Sales – By State

Colorado

Kiandra Burnham 

Director of Sales

O: 720-283-1722 W:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jonathan Flores

Management CO

Director of Inside Sales

M: 720-283-1722 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Texas

Sales Agents – By State

Arizona

Carlos Cubillo

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 602-761-0411 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tanya Dye

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 602-291-7388 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Eric Broadbent

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 928-245-0800 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

John Willis

Personal Lines Sales AZ

O: 602-565-1929 W: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kyle Oldfield

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 480-236-0793 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Brookanne Kraus

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 480-469-2346 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kevin Horn

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 602-717-5479 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Joseph (Joe) Yard

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 402-680-3827 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Mark Taylor 

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 480-276-8656 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Robert Tibbs

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 602-568-6295 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tara Hornbeck

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 708-337-0337 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Brandon Aldrich

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 520-425-7771 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Marco Garcia

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 928-580-8477 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Antoine Logan

Personal Lines Sales AZ

M: 623-374-1334 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

California

Rida Bangush

Personal Lines Sales CA

M: 818-536-1005 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Shirley Murphy

Personal Lines Sales CA

M: 626-394-7043 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Cristal Garcia-Villanueva

Personal Lines Sales CA

M: 818-836-4607 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Nathan Weiss

Personal Lines Sales CA

M: 619-736-0513 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Colorado

Kendal Liedtke

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-833-8421 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Edward Anicka Jr. 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-868-0748 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

David Marcus

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-968-6632 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Mike Brath 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-239-3990 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tiffany Clark 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-931-8904 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Dan Baumgarten 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-638-0860 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jeff Dillehey

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-810-4165 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Paul Bremer 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-859-4969 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Belkis Trewin

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 719-208-2682 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Niki Elvanian 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-587-9530 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Yurany Dunn 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-361-5798  O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Olivia Jamison 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-898-1641 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Trevor Runyon 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-440-4392  O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Miriam Wilson

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 710-367-8198 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Gary (Scott) Dent 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-412-7430 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jamie Ryman 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 952-261-5712 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Francis “Dane” Ingram 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-332-7171 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Ted Jamison 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-946-3559 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Doug Klich 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-887-2738 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jared Jarnagin

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-913-0399 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Silk Mettam 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M:720-323-4556 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Logan Willis 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M:720-707-0202 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Christina Staten

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-519-4575 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Ryan Mulhern 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-903-2389 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Zachary (Zach) Moore 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M:561-866-0087 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Ricky Mucciaccio 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 678-699-0431 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Morgan Busch

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-450-6093 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Charles (Chaz) Osen 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-917-0476 O:  720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tivoli Martin

Personal Lines Sales CO

M:843-442-8865 O:  720-283-1722

*protected email*

Justin Spelic 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-283-2216 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Matthew McCarthy

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-339-6107 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Christopher Mathisen 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-906-7153 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kyle Semler

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-513-6898 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Van Saukam

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-939-0270 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Stephanie Schoenauer

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-834-2911 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Brian Weiher

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-564-5070 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jonathan Cencich

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-249-0423 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Maxwell Hearn 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-254-8240 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

John Wren 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-476-8442 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Timothy Morgan

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-870-7236  O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Shomar Vernon

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-521-1908 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tracy Wiley

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-331-0619  O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tracie Romero 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-564-4908 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jeff Berry 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-253-4955 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Brittany Brister

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 727-710-5153 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Sean Mulhern

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-709-4440 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Emerald Felix

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 970-343-2117 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Nick Alberts 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-594-6014 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Maria Lah

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-402-2763 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Destinee Barron

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-236-0032 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Brendon Doran 

Personal Lines Service CO

M: 720-999-7816 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Randy Andrade

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 970-371-8558 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Andy Denton

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 720-951-4642 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Nick Alberts 

Personal Lines Sales CO

M: 303-594-6014 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Mauricio Teran 

Personal Lines Service CO

O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Tannea Musselman

Personal Lines Service CO

M: 303-775-4473 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Taylor Fisher 

Personal Lines Service CO

M: 970-839-4387 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kansas

Belinda Counts  

Personal Lines Sales KS

M: 417-425-0993 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Francis Degnan 

Personal Lines Sales KS

M: 816-309-3138 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Missouri

Natalie Bone 

Personal Lines Sales MO

M: 314-566-4541 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Andrea Johnson

Personal Line Sales MO

M: 816-308-7289 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Stan Saunders

Personal Line Sales MO

M: 660-752-7634 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Nevada
Oregon
Martin Schwarzbach

Personal Lines Sales OR

M: 541-705-7985 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Raec (Race) Schwarzbach

Personal Lines Sales OR

M: 541-980-7271 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Texas

Humberto Cazarez 

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 956-436-4884 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Malisa McCown 

Personal Lines Sales TX

M:512-431-8503 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Annie Parchman

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 432-352-4472 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

William “Bill” Jager, Jr

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 469-859-1477 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Diana Smith

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 817-559-2159 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Johnny Cavazos

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 956-454-5965

*protected email*

Carl Myers 

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 214-557-2896 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Michelle Watson

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 432-250-8692 O:720-283-1722

*protected email*

Damon Tipping

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 432-693-3855 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Oscar Escobar

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 915-887-8253 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Brandon Burden

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 972-365-7698 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Wallace Williams

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 214-709-4387 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Melissa Roberts

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 432-559-5160 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jennifer Burden

Personal Lines Sales TX

M: 214-783-4249 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Utah

Thomas Jones

Personal Lines Sales UT

M: 801-824-0074 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Suzie Wood

Personal Lines Sales UT

M: 801-882-3428 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Washington

Ania Velasco

Personal Lines Sales WA

M: 206-267-8184 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

 

Alexander Illig

Personal Lines Sales WA

M: 253-514-1696 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Scott Mulhern

Personal Lines Sales WA

253-732-4871 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Service Team

Kelsey Reeves

Licensed Remote Customer Service Representative

O: 720-306-6926 F: 720-293-2670

*protected email*

 

Ashleigh Moore 

Customer Service Supervisor

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Candy Polanco 

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Nubia Ponce 

Personal Lines Service CO

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kate Petree 

Licensed Customer Service Representative

Remote CSR

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Matthew Stamey

Live Remote Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kristen Delacerda

Personal Lines Service CO

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Michelle Scarbrough 

Personal Lines Service CO

Licensed Remote Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Lindsey Johnson

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O:  720-283-1722

*protected email*

James Harris

Service Team

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Jason Holtorf 

Service Team

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Bobbi Pettit

Licensed Customer Service Representative

O:  720-283-1722

*protected email*

Teresa Brady

Licensed Customer Service Representative

M: 720-383-1306 O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Auditing Team

Jazlynn Heredia

Auditing Team CO

Processing Assistant

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Karla Ponce

Auditing Team CO

Auditing Specialists

O:  720-283-1722

*protected email*

Titus Cheshire

Auditing Team CO

Auditing Specialists

O: 720-283-1722

*protected e-mail*

Alva Avila

Auditing Team CO

Processing Assistant

O: 720-283-1722

*protected e-mail*

Administration Team 

Evie O’Brien 

Administration Team CO

Administrator/Human Resources

O: 720-283-1722

*protected email*

Kate Petree went above and beyond to find me a better policy for both my home and auto. I appreciated her knowledge and how she was able to explain the benefits, etc. of my policies. On a side note, I work in a real estate office and she also quickly assisted a client of mine with his policy. Greatly appreciated!

Shawn Jaeger on the business team is THE best! I’ve shopped around a ton for insurance and he has beat the pricing and the coverage hands down! The best part is that he genuinely cares and listens to your needs. With our company we are creating a scaling plan and he is not only quoting to help provide forecasting info for us, he is also helping make a plan based off our needs. Great family guy, honest, and helpful. I’m super pleased and highly recommend. Thanks Shawn!

What a great experience. They gave me several options with different companies and did an outstanding job explaining the differences. Most companies just sell you their own companies policy. I was able to get a great policy that was within my budget.

Disclaimer: Insurance coverage cannot be bound or changed via submission of any online form/application provided on this site or otherwise, email, voice mail, fax nor any social media page. No binder, insurance policy, change, addition, and/or deletion to insurance coverage will go into effect until confirmed directly by a licensed agent.

FIND US

7901 Southpark Plaza #110,

Littleton, CO 80120

8am-5pm Monday - Friday

CONTACT US

720.283.1722

Fax: 720.283.1726

Service@CissInsurance.com

The success of Colorado Insurance is dependent upon building and maintaining goodwill with our customers. We are committed to the protection of the privacy of those using our website and services. By using our website, or providing us with personal information, you are accepting the practices described in this Privacy Policy. If you do not agree with any term in this Privacy Policy, do not provide us your personal information or use our website, including live chat services.
READ MORE