Endless insurance possibilities
for wherever life takes you.


Our Premier Carrier Partners


...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...


Insurance Products

Auto Insurance

Will you take the path less traveled? Our ability to find you coverage with more than 10 carriers will help you navigate anywhere with confidence.

Home & Renter’s Insurance

There’s no place like home, which is why our knowledgeable agents work diligently to get you the best insurance price without sacrificing coverage.

Toy Insurance

Looking to insure your favorite big kid toys? Ride freely with our ATV, RV, motorcycle and boat policies designed to secure all your on and off-road adventures.

Umbrella Insurance

Like an insurance safety net, umbrella policies can extend your current coverage to protect you and your family from a catastrophic event so that if it rains…it won’t pour.

Let us save you money

Our Retention

Our Customers

Our Happy Clients

We are Number 1 in The State

Service Center

Schedule an Annual Review
Just like the Colorado Aspen leaves, carrier premiums can change annually. Let’s make sure you still have the best policy to give you peace of mind for the year to come.
Make a Policy Change
With our dedicated service team, adding a new vehicle, home policy, or updating your current one is always a breeze.
Request ID Cards or Declaration Pages
Have your auto ID cards, auto declaration pages, or home declaration pages delivered digitally so you always know your coverages and have them on hand.

Responses from our Customers

WHO IS COLORADO INSURANCE

Colorado Insurance Mission Statement

To effectively ATTRACT, CONVERT, OPTIMIZE and RETAIN quality clients. To become your trusted insurance partner by protecting individuals and families from unexpected financial disaster using quality products from financially sound insurance carriers. To allow all agency members to share in the profit of the company in order to establish financial security and freedom for themselves and their families.

Reasons to use Colorado Insurance ?

Service Department:

  • We have our own in-house team of licensed professionals to personally manage all our clients.  Our clients will never have to dial a “1-800” number or deal with a random call center.  We pride ourselves on first class, localized service.  Your client will know your account manager personally, we want to create clients for life built on solid relationships.

Coverage:

  • We believe in the concept of proper coverage. We pride ourselves on making sure our clients are properly insured.  We understand that price is important; however properly protecting your most valuable assets is always our number one priority. 

Our relationship with you

Relationship  As an independent agency, we work for the client, and not the insurance carrier.  We want to develop long lasting relationships with all our clients. Our mission is to provide the best available products through the best available carrier at the most competitive price.  We know that once a client chooses our agency they will never need to move or shop insurance ever again. By managing a client's insurance portfolio in house through our localized service team, we personally guarantee they will not become “just another number.”  Our clients are our top priority. We understand that first class service is the only true way to build a solid relationship.  

Our family

Colorado Insurance is a family owned and operated independent insurance agency, specializing in Auto, Home, Toys and Life Insurance. We have been serving our business partners and their clients since 1994. We have established ourselves as the premier insurance provider in the Mountain West Region. Our philosophy is built on the foundation of providing industry leading products, at market competitive prices, coupled with first class client service. In the summer of 2019 Colorado Insurance was acquired by Peter C. Foy Insurance Services of the West, shortened to PCF. This was a strategic move to strengthen our contracts and presence with the multitude of carriers that we use. You may receive paperwork with PCF listed as the agency and this is not a typo. Since we are a part of the PCF family now, some of our client contracts will come through them. They are a fantastic company to be a part of and we are proud to work hand in hand with them every day.




COLORADO INSURANCE EXECUTIVE LEADERS

team-photo

Mike Mathisen

President

team-photo

Sarah Zambrano

Operations Director

team-photo

Rob Oldenburg

Outside Sales Business Development




team-photo

Kirsten Jones

Inside Sales Business Development

team-photo

Molly Lura

Customer Service Manager

team-photo

Ashleigh Moore

Customer Service Controller